Collaborative overload


There is another side of the coin when it comes to collaboration: it seems like time spent in collaborative activities such as meetings, calls, and emails has risen by 50% or more in recent decades, often consuming up to 80% of a typical workweek and leaving little time for individual tasks.

That’s why, while collaboration can enhance organizational success, it can also overwhelm employees, leading to stress, burnout, and decreased performance.

The burden of collaboration is unevenly distributed: about 3% to 5% of employees contribute to 20% to 35% of value-added collaborations. These high contributors, often known for being helpful, become bottlenecks as their workload escalates, and their effectiveness diminishes. Their contributions often go unnoticed due to the dispersed nature of their work across various teams and locations.

Employees invest three types of collaborative resources: informational (knowledge and skills), social (network access), and personal (time and energy). Unlike informational and social resources, personal resources are finite and often overused. Requests that could be met with informational or social support frequently demand personal engagement, unnecessarily draining time and energy.

To address these challenges, organizations can streamline collaborative efforts and recognize valuable contributions:

  1. Redistribute Collaborative Work: Use surveys, communication tracking, and network analysis to identify overloaded employees. Encourage behavioral changes by teaching employees to filter requests, set boundaries, and prioritize value-adding tasks. Technology and strategic office layouts can make informational and social resources more accessible, reducing personal demands on key contributors. Structural changes, such as delegating decision rights and creating roles dedicated to managing collaboration requests, can further alleviate pressure.

  2. Reward Effective Collaboration: Recognize both individual achievement and collaborative contributions through performance reviews, peer recognition, and metrics that value teamwork. Ensuring fair acknowledgment of collaborative efforts is particularly important for women, who often bear a disproportionate share of collaborative work but receive less recognition.

Leaders must promote balanced and efficient collaboration to prevent key employees from becoming overwhelmed. Establishing roles like chief collaboration officers could help organizations manage teamwork strategically, ensuring that the collaborative efforts enhance rather than hinder overall performance.

The evolution of collaboration in an increasingly digital world

How much human collaboration has been affected from the from the ever-increasing expansion of remote working? Well, a lot. Thanks to the article  "The Profound Influence of Small Choices in Digital Collaboration" we delve into how remote work has increased reliance on digital collaboration tools. How do features of these tools—specifically, privacy versus transparency—steer the direction of creativity, and how can managers leverage these tools to drive the most productive forms of collaboration?

The study emphasizes two important dynamics that impact creativity: transparency and privacy. Transparent collaborations engage with a broader organizational community, facilitating diverse, spontaneous connections that can spark creativity through varied perspectives. Private collaborations, on the other hand, create intimate, trust-based environments where team members can take risks, challenge norms, and develop novel ideas. Both transparency and privacy have their own advantages, but they foster distinct types of creativity.

Drawing parallels from physical workplace design, where open-plan offices have their pros and cons, digital platforms offer greater flexibility. They allow teams to choose between public channels (transparent) and private channels (closed), depending on the needs of a specific project.

Two Distinct Creative Paths

The research distinguishes between developmental creativity and disruptive creativity. Developmental creativity, which emerges from transparent settings, involves expanding on existing ideas by collaborating with a wide network of individuals. Disruptive creativity, fostered in private settings, centers around challenging and reframing problems, often leading to groundbreaking innovations.

Managers can facilitate both paths by aligning the right communication structure with the specific needs of a project. For instance, a public forum may be more suitable when expanding on existing knowledge, while a private space may nurture creative breakthroughs by encouraging risk-taking.

Practical Examples

In a transparent setting, an employee solving a problem regarding recycling methods reached out in a public forum. This led to unexpected, valuable input from a colleague in another region, showcasing how transparency bridges diverse knowledge sources. Conversely, a private group working on reimagining organizational processes was able to engage in deep, candid discussions, fostering a level of trust and creativity not possible in public settings.

Designing for Creativity

To maximize creativity in digital environments, managers should consider three key points:

  1. Select tools that allow both public and private spaces: Different projects require different types of creativity, so offering both transparent and private channels is essential.

  2. Support private groups, even without oversight: Trusting teams to operate in private and finding ways to share insights from these spaces with the wider organization without undermining their creative safety is crucial.

  3. Combine different groups to support varied creative paths: Using a mix of transparent and private settings in sequence or simultaneously can lead to both incremental improvements and groundbreaking innovations. Teams may start privately to develop risky, disruptive ideas, and later shift to a public channel for broader development.By making thoughtful decisions about when to use transparency or privacy, leaders can guide their teams toward the type of creativity—whether developmental or disruptive—that best suits their goals. Understanding these nuances enables organizations to fully unlock the creative potential of their digital workforce.

The importance of embracing agile

BE AGILE. 

What does it mean?

Agile is equivalent to fast. No, not really. Not only that.

In the first place, being agile has to do with simplicity which, as a quote from Charlie Chaplin reminds us, is not an easy thing to achieve at all. We live immersed in an ecosystem, in a system of networks and information nodes. As managers we are increasingly called upon to do the job of designers, psychologists and philosophers: intercept weak signals, translate them and pool them to respond in a personalized way to our client's needs, to greatly reduce time-to-market how much the costs.

“Think simple, act fast”: this is the real key to any future organization.

In practice, an agile organization adopts processes, tools and learning approaches that allow it to respond in an appropriate manner and time to market changes and technological transformation.

Agile methodologies, initially developed for the IT sector, have transformed software development over the past 25 to 30 years, leading to higher success rates, better quality, faster market delivery, and enhanced team motivation and productivity. These methods, characterized by new values, principles, and practices, offer a stark contrast to traditional command-and-control management styles.

Today, agile practices are spreading beyond IT to a wide range of industries and business functions, including media, manufacturing, marketing, logistics, and even into executive leadership. Agile’s emphasis on self-managed, cross-functional teams focused on customer needs is driving profitable growth and nurturing a new breed of versatile general managers.

However, the adoption of agile outside IT faces challenges. Many executives lack a deep understanding of agile principles, often knowing just enough to use buzzwords without truly grasping the methodology. This superficial knowledge can lead to management practices that conflict with agile principles, undermining team effectiveness. Common issues include launching too many initiatives simultaneously, spreading talent too thin, micromanaging teams, overriding team decisions, and imposing excessive controls, all of which dilute the benefits of agile innovation.

Agile is fundamentally about fostering innovation, which is critical for companies in today’s fast-paced, dynamic business environment. While less applicable to routine operations, agile thrives in settings that demand constant innovation in both products and internal processes. Companies that create environments conducive to agile practices find their teams can innovate more rapidly and effectively.

Based on extensive consulting and research, six key practices have been identified that leaders should adopt to fully leverage agile's potential. These practices are crucial for fostering a culture where agile methodologies can thrive, leading to sustained innovation and competitive advantage.

Understanding and Applying Agile: Fundamentals and Limitations

Many executives have a superficial understanding of what agile truly means. Some associate it with anarchy, thinking it allows everyone to do whatever they want, while others see it as a way to do what they say, just faster. In reality, agile is neither of these. There are different forms of agile, each with common principles but different focuses. The main forms include:

  1. Learn How Agile Really Works: agile comes in several varieties, such as scrum, which emphasizes creative and adaptive teamwork in solving complex problems; lean development, which focuses on the continual elimination of waste; and kanban, which concentrates on reducing lead times and the amount of work in process.

  2. Understand Where Agile Does or Does Not Work: Agile is not a panacea, you have to find the right conditions for it and most importantly, Agile innovation also depends on having a cadre of eager participants. “Build projects around motivated individuals. Give them the environment and support they need, and trust them to get the job done.”

  3. Start Small and Let the Word Spread: the most successful introductions of agile usually start small. They often begin in IT, where software developers are likely to be familiar with the principles. Then agile might spread to another function, with the original practitioners acting as coaches.

  4. Allow “Master” Teams to Customize Their Practices: before beginning to modify or customize agile, a person or team will benefit from practicing the widely used methodologies that have delivered success in thousands of companies.

  5. Practice Agile at the Top: strategy development and resource allocation are examples of activities where agile methodologies are perfectly suited. Senior executives who come together as an agile team and learn to apply the discipline to these activities achieve far-reaching benefits. Their own productivity and morale improve. They speak the language of the teams they are empowering.

  6. Destroy the Barriers to Agile Behaviors: research by Scrum Alliance, an independent nonprofit with 400,000-plus members, has found that more than 70% of agile practitioners report tension between their teams and the rest of the organization. Little wonder: They are following different road maps and moving at different speeds. So how can we destroy these barriers?

  7. First, Align Everyone with a Common Vision. When different teams work on separate components of complex issues, they must all align with the organization’s key priorities. Even if not every team uses agile methods, they should still work from the same priority list. For instance, if developing a new mobile app is the highest priority for the software team, it should be the same for budgeting, testing, and integration. Without this alignment, agile efforts will face challenges. Ensuring this falls under the responsibility of an agile executive team.

Then, start by Modifying Roles, Not Structures. Some executives mistakenly think that building more cross-functional teams requires a major organizational restructure. This is rarely the case. Empowered, cross-functional teams do require a matrix management system, but the focus should be on fostering collaboration among different departments, working concurrently rather than sequentially. Assign One Decision-Maker per Task. While individuals may report to multiple leaders, decisions cannot be made by more than one person. In an agile setup, it should be clear who is accountable for key tasks such as assembling teams, choosing leaders, and making final decisions. A senior executive typically oversees this, ensuring each innovation initiative has a dedicated owner. Other leaders should provide support but refrain from undermining decisions. If necessary, change the person in charge rather than undermining their authority.

Prioritize Team Success Over Individual Achievements. Research shows that while individual intelligence influences team performance, the collective intelligence of a group is even more crucial—and easier to enhance. Agile teams employ facilitators to help improve their collective intelligence by refining roles, resolving conflicts, and encouraging equal participation. Metrics should shift from focusing on individual productivity to measuring team results and overall satisfaction. Recognition and rewards should prioritize team accomplishments.

Lead by Asking Questions, Not Giving Orders. General George S. Patton Jr. once advised leaders to avoid dictating how tasks should be done. Instead, tell people what needs to be achieved, and let them surprise you with their creativity. Agile leaders guide through questions like “What do you suggest?” or “How can we test that?” This approach fosters growth among functional experts and promotes a shift from siloed teams competing for resources to collaborative, cross-functional groups.

Agile methodologies have transformed the software industry, one of the most rapidly evolving sectors in business over the past three decades. Now, agile principles are extending beyond IT to transform other functions in various industries. The biggest challenge today isn’t proving agile’s effectiveness but changing executive behaviors. Leaders who embrace agile’s expansion will drive faster, more profitable growth.

Credits: Harvard Business Review - Embracing Agile. How to master the process that’s transforming management, by Darrell Rigby, Jeff Sutherland, and Hirotaka Takeuchi

Strategically Engaging With Innovation Ecosystems

Strategically Engaging With Innovation Ecosystems

“Competitive pressure to innovate is driving companies to seek new ideas well beyond their own walls. But sponsoring the occasional hackathon or having one-off, uncoordinated interactions with a startup accelerator won’t contribute much to boosting an organization’s innovation capabilities. Many companies are missing an opportunity that’s close to home by overlooking or failing to effectively tap innovation ecosystems in their regions”.

Superare il paradigma del tu perdi e io vinco. Oltre i silos aziendali!

🚀Trasformare i Silos Funzionali per un'organizzazione collaborativa 🚀

In un mondo che si muove velocemente verso l'integrazione e l'innovazione continua, le organizzazioni affrontano una sfida cruciale: abbattere i silos funzionali per favorire un ambiente di collaborazione e visione trasversale. In Smartive, crediamo fermamente che la forza di un'organizzazione risieda nella sua capacità di unire diversità e visioni differenti in un unico tessuto organizzativo, superando il tradizionale paradigma dei giochi a somma zero - dove la vittoria di uno significa la sconfitta dell'altro.

 

🌈 Diversità e Complessità: verso una Nuova Cultura Organizzativa🌈

Sempre più spesso nei nostri journey di cambiamento affrontiamo il tema del rinnovamento culturale partendo da valori e comportamenti che promuovono l'interconnessione e l'interdipendenza. Riconosciamo che ogni individuo all'interno dell'organizzazione può contribuire in maniera unica alla realizzazione di una visione condivisa, superando i confini funzionali per abbracciare una prospettiva più ampia e arricchita. Sempre più è importante saper comunicare per orientare e orientarsi in un sistema complesso (che tendiamo a rendere complicato) come può essere l'organizzazione aziendale.

 

💡 Per questo articolo grazie all'ispirazione #MauroCeruti 💡

Mauro Ceruti ha ispirato questa riflessione attraverso il contributo anticipato sull'inserto della Domenica del Sole 24 ORE e che presenterà al convegno "Abitare le diversità: culture e complessità nuove" a Firenze, mette in luce l'importanza di superare i vecchi paradigmi per abbracciare la complessità e la ricchezza che la diversità porta nelle nostre vite e all'interno di quell'ecosistema che è il mondo che abitiamo. 

 

🤝 Invito alla Collaborazione 🤝

In questo inizio di aprile raccogliamo e rilanciamo quello che Mauro Ceruti definisce un "pactum unionis": per essere a prova di futuro dobbiamo accogliere una sfida tanto a livello planetario quanto a livello organizzativo ovvero costruire un senso di comunità possibile solo se sostituiremo le pratiche di dialogo a quelle di forza, le pratiche dell'apprendimento comune per abbracciare il cambiamento e superare le crisi (anche quelle climatiche).